Critical Fashion - Yasha Nydoorin, Modern

Critical Fashion - Yasha Nydoorin, Modern
Critical Fashion - Yasha Nydoorin, Modern

Critical Fashion - Yasha Nydoorin, modern

More Posts from Aarcanaa and Others

4 years ago

hi why do you ship gawain with lancelot? not trying to start shit im just curious

God so this is a true fact but I’ve been thinking about them since sophomore year of high school (i'm a college sophomore now) so this is going to be lengthy and involved. But i think Lancelot and Gawain have a really interesting dynamic as well as a lot of support in text which i think makes them compelling.

    In a lot of ways they are equals in a way neither of them is with anyone else-- they are, in the vulgate at least, the two best knights in the world, the two arthur trusts most and who are famous even among other good knights. Its almost isolating, that level of renown, and you see that Lancelot in particular is uncomfortable with it, though they both at times have stories of trying to escape their own names. Of course they would understand each other in a way no one else could.

    Despite the fact that Lancelot quite literally steals his place as number one, gawain is never resentful of this, never upset to lose to lancelot. In fact he seems very happy to sing his praises to anyone he meets, like in Lancelot and the Hart with the White Foot, where he says of lancelot that “He is the best knight alive in the entire world, and moreover the most handsome.”

    In the stanzaic morte, he tells elaine of shallot that 

“Such a leman as thou hast one,

 In all this world ne be no mo.

There is no lady of flesh ne bone

In this worlde so thrive or thro,

Though her herte were steel or stone,

That might her love holde him fro.”

Or, translated,

Such a love as you have, 

there’s no better in the world.

There is no lady of flesh or bone,

In this world so lucky or stubborn

Though her heart were steel or stone,

She could stop it  from loving him.’

In the vulgate hes constantly running after lancelot, happy to play sidekick as long as it means lancelot's company. He pretty infamously says this about lancelot:

Then Sir Gawain thought a little, like a man who believed he would never be well again. “If God were to grant me my health,” he said, “I’d immediately wish to be the most beautiful maiden in the world, happy and healthy, on condition that he would love me above all others, all his life and mine.”

I think this is really interesting because its not a devotion gawain shows to anyone else outside of his family. Hes oddly protective of lancelot, considering he can very well fend for himself usually. In the dutch hart, he literally tracks down and kills a man who hurt lancelot, before tying his body to his horse and dragging it around like achilles. He also rescues and heals him in morien, gets the whole court in a tizzy looking for him after a battle with galehaut where he spends a year searching, drags lancelots poor cousins all over looking for him after a tournament, freaks out when he goes missing in the hart (: “He lamented more grievously than anyone ever will, or had ever done before, because he thought he had lost Lancelot, the daring knight.”) like jesus gawain calm down.

He explicitly forsakes his devotion and duty to the country in favour of lancelot; in morien, hes called to take his place as king because arthur is gone, and he refuses in favour of, you guessed it, running after lancelot.  In chretien it is said that 

“Now I will tell you the truth, and you must not think I lie, that Gawain would not wish to be chosen king, unless he had Lancelot with him. “

And he lies to arthurs face multiple times in the vulgate and morte to hide lancelot's various crimes.

Speaking of crimes, theyre both uh, well. Literal serial killers. And you know its good to have hobbies in common in a relationship. No but seriously they represent a lot of the darker parts of knighthood. From lancelots bit with the proud knight in kotc to gawains… what can be only described as massacres in the dutch texts. They both have very odd relationships with death, with gawain so familiar with it by being surrounded by violence from a young age that it no longer affects him, while lancelot is almost the opposite-- its very distant to him. 

I think thats another reason i like them; theyre similar in a lot of ways but in just as many they are opposites. Gawains whole deal is being charming, manipulative, educated and good with words. Lancelot is in contrast, especially in chretien and the vulgate, at his most inept in social situations. You note that in the hart, its gawain that has to talk him out of the marriage he accidentally agreed to (“ But he does not at this time wish to marry you-- you must understand...”) etc.  while gawain is centered at court in a web of political alliances, lancelot is a fair unknown, who can and does disappear for years and generally avoid court when he can. I think they work well as a team because of this.

Lancelot certainly think so, at least in the morien: Quoth Sir Lancelot: "By the Lord who made me, and who shall be Doom's-man at the last day, come what may thereof, since Sir Gawain rideth hence 'tis not I will bide behind!”

He isnt as quotable outside of one specific scene ill get to later, and most of what he does say is in aside to himself, like the lengthy speech he gives in knight of the cart while debating to himself why gawain has failed to rescue him, and if this means gawain doesn’t love him (“He ought indeed to receive your aid whom you used to love so devotedly! For my part I may truly say that there is no lodging place or retreat on either side of the sea, where I would not have searched for you at least seven or ten years before finding you, if I knew you to be in prison. But why do I thus torment myself? You do not care for me even enough to take this trouble.”) trust me it goes on like this for quite a while. 

On a side note, i think its a bit reminiscent of a scene from the vulgate where gawain thinks that lancelot is in  love with elaine of shallot--

 “That night he thought a lot about Lancelot and said to himself that he would not have thought that Lancelot would have aspired to leave his heart in any place that was not nobler and more honourable than all others. ‘And yet,’ he said, ‘I cannot really blame him if he loves this girl… (he goes on in debate with himself)...

    That night Sir Gawain slept very little, because he was thinking of the girl and Lancelot,”

the morte specifically calls gawain the man lancelot loves most in the world, according to a prophecy of merlins. Then, the kicker: he kills gawains brothers on accident, gawain swears to kill him in revenge, and lancelot…. Refuses to kill gawain, or even to renounce love for him. When asked about the fight, he says:

 “I do not know what the outcome will be, but I do know that if I were the winner and ought to cut off his head, I should not be able to kill him for all the world, because I think he is too noble. Moreover, he is the man, out of all those in the world that have meant anything to me, that I have most loved, and still do,”

Gawain forgives him on his deathbed and writes a letter, the entirety of which i implore you to read. He begs lancelot’s forgiveness and for him to return from france and see gawains tomb, “for all the love that was betwixt us”

I think you could interpret this as a very passionate friendship, certainly, but i am gay and so i think they are too. Not only because of the texts but because of the fact that their dynamic is fun and interesting and they work well together.

Oh, and if anyone was wondering why i call them remarkable, here is another quote from the vulgate, following the first fight with gawain:

‘It is certainly remarkable of you,’ said King Bors, ‘to love him so deeply when he hates you mortally.’

‘Find it remarkable if you wish,’ replied Lancelot, ‘but he will never be able to hate me so much that I stop loving him.’


Tags
4 years ago
Heyyyyy Everyone!!! People Have Been Talking About How There Are A Lot Of Underappreciated Side Characters

heyyyyy everyone!!! people have been talking about how there are a lot of underappreciated side characters in arthuriana, so me and some friends figured we could do a side characters appreciation week, especially with female and/or poc characters who don’t get talked about much. we’re going to make content for these characters starting on monday with elaine of shalott, plus ahead-of-time info sheets on them for anyone who wants to join in!! :)


Tags
4 years ago
Is She Trying To Warn It Or Sink It? 

Is she trying to warn it or sink it? 

INSTAGRAM | SHOP 

Please, do not repost, but feel free to reblog!


Tags
4 years ago
Poppy Fields In Umbria, Italy.
Poppy Fields In Umbria, Italy.
Poppy Fields In Umbria, Italy.

Poppy fields in Umbria, Italy.


Tags
3 years ago
Hello! I Did A Thing For Nova And Mali's "Classics...but Make It Gay" Art Book! The Pre-orders Are Closed

Hello! I did a thing for Nova and Mali's "Classics...but make it gay" art book! The pre-orders are closed at the moment but I think they'll reopen again in winter/fall so please keep an eye on their twitter page if you'll like a copy! Everyone in it is amazing and I am very thankful for being accepted for the project! I did a reinterpretation of Leighton's "God Speed" because I just want an excuse to paint two knights staring lovingly at each other haha > <

3 years ago
Self Portrait As A Dog Seeing Itself In A Mirror 

self portrait as a dog seeing itself in a mirror 

  • bakerstreetirregular7
    bakerstreetirregular7 liked this · 2 years ago
  • fiveshotsofjager
    fiveshotsofjager reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • fiveshotsofjager
    fiveshotsofjager liked this · 2 years ago
  • souxfle
    souxfle liked this · 2 years ago
  • fairyinabottle
    fairyinabottle liked this · 3 years ago
  • luckbandit
    luckbandit liked this · 3 years ago
  • outsainted
    outsainted liked this · 3 years ago
  • piratearrowxab
    piratearrowxab liked this · 3 years ago
  • th3-savi0r
    th3-savi0r liked this · 3 years ago
  • bebelux
    bebelux liked this · 3 years ago
  • theultracheeseburger
    theultracheeseburger liked this · 3 years ago
  • secondstorycottage
    secondstorycottage liked this · 3 years ago
  • cryptidnova
    cryptidnova liked this · 3 years ago
  • blasphemyallfightsarenecessary
    blasphemyallfightsarenecessary liked this · 3 years ago
  • theunforgivenscone
    theunforgivenscone liked this · 3 years ago
  • midnight-dreamingsouls
    midnight-dreamingsouls liked this · 3 years ago
  • fakehouseresident
    fakehouseresident liked this · 3 years ago
  • punkiy50
    punkiy50 reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • punkiy50
    punkiy50 liked this · 3 years ago
  • iamthecheesesandwitch
    iamthecheesesandwitch liked this · 3 years ago
  • alleged-mothman
    alleged-mothman liked this · 3 years ago
  • izzyhcnds
    izzyhcnds liked this · 3 years ago
  • forgottenmemoria
    forgottenmemoria liked this · 3 years ago
  • valengory1234
    valengory1234 liked this · 3 years ago
  • leede-ly
    leede-ly liked this · 3 years ago
  • missmajonnaise
    missmajonnaise liked this · 3 years ago
  • analviel
    analviel liked this · 3 years ago
  • asemifunctioninghuman
    asemifunctioninghuman liked this · 3 years ago
  • eclipseyeger
    eclipseyeger liked this · 4 years ago
  • wanderingbasilisk
    wanderingbasilisk liked this · 4 years ago
  • saphire-sweater
    saphire-sweater liked this · 4 years ago
  • keslyk
    keslyk liked this · 4 years ago
  • sunshine-hugs
    sunshine-hugs liked this · 4 years ago
  • dawn-shrouded
    dawn-shrouded reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • eclecticblazeruins
    eclecticblazeruins liked this · 4 years ago
  • nose235678
    nose235678 liked this · 4 years ago
  • starlight-persephone
    starlight-persephone reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • dreamingofancientshadows
    dreamingofancientshadows liked this · 4 years ago
  • abiwilsonn
    abiwilsonn liked this · 4 years ago
  • aarcanaa
    aarcanaa reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • sarcastic-feminist-witch
    sarcastic-feminist-witch reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • hopelesslyromanticdepressedbitch
    hopelesslyromanticdepressedbitch liked this · 4 years ago
  • sarcastic-feminist-witch
    sarcastic-feminist-witch reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • sarcastic-feminist-witch
    sarcastic-feminist-witch liked this · 4 years ago

109 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags