I just noticed Lilia is the only witch who actually called them a Coven. "I needed you, my coven"
And in the next episode Billy calls Agatha nothing but a covenless witch (and she doesn’t actually denies this).
Wanda's powers create illusions. The hex wasn't real the people saw the Sitcom Land because Wanda was mind contolling them.
Billy's powers create reality. The coven wasn't mind controlled by him (exepect that scene after Alice's death). The road wasn't real until Billy made it real. He closed his door but because how his powers work any coven who sings the Ballad will be met with the door.
Billy believes (believed) the road was real, he also believes is the Ballad is the key for the road so now it is.
Ok but like what was Agatha's plan for Billy?
The witches road was fake. She was planning on having the girls blast her so she could steal their magick but what about Billy? He was the one who asked Agatha to take him there. What was she planning on doing about the random teenager at her house?
Was she hoping the Salem Seven would have killed him? Would she have killed him?
Did anyone else catch the parallel between Wanda leaving Westview after undoing the Hex vs Billy leaving after Agatha's death?
And just like that Nick kept helping his mother kill witches even when he was dead.
I really hope they give Billy a better suit for next projects bc this one is super ugly.
Like use the one with galaxies on the side (ik wich one rigth?) for his next suit up scene.
Jen, my lovely Jen, i'm so happy for her but i really hope we see her again.
I admit i was wrong. The road is fake, or was until Billy decided it was real (it's just so nice when people are creative with reality magick)
The Road changes and adapt to the coven. Agatha surviving it the first time doesn’t actually help them at all.
It's safe to assume Agatha would have walked the Road for the first time (assuming she did walk) around the 1600's around the time her coven would have tried to get her killed (Personal theory/ headcanon that it's not important for this post).
Of course the road from 2024 looks different than the road of 1600, not only they are centruies apart but the coven its different.
Agatha may not understand most of the trials, because the trials are personal to the witch being tested, but she knew to not drink the wine on Jen's trial this shows some type of knowledgement about a idea of what the trial was.
I know is unpopular idea but i believe Agatha walked the road before (and its part of my headcanon about how she got her magick stealing abilities)
My theory for Billy's memorie loss is: The westview/ Billy Maximoff memories was mostly because if the sigil (Who i believe was put to protect Billy Maximoff not William Kaplan)
And the memories of Billy Kaplan are lost because of the head injury he got on the car (i mean there was A LOT of blood on his head, it was going down to his shirt). I mean the doctors did said some memory loss was normal.
Of course we have to consider that (different from the comics) Billy Kaplan is technically dead since the car accident so that is a chance of Billy never having the memories of his first 13 years of life back (and if marvel was more willing to do a more Horror story they would make a perfect character for it).
But either way Billy only have memories of Jeff and Rebecca being his parents for the last 3 years and i will take this little piece of the real Billy Kaplan that we sadly will never get to meet
Billy and Tommy were created in the Hex, where they went from babies- to five years old-to ten years old- to be killed in about five-six weeks.
If the sigil was the reason Billy couldn't remember anything pre-accident (wich i believe it was) That means he just got all of his memories back, both as Billy Maximoff and William Kaplan. That includes 13 years of being the son of Rabecca and Jeff Kaplan and the weeks of being the son of Wanda Maximoff.
We all saw him when he woke up after the car crash as Billy Maximoff he was scared. And ok Agatha was mocking him but she was rigth Wanda chose a town full of strangers over him and Tommy (There’s was nothing stopping her from recreating their Sitcom land instead of that farm we saw her in MoM).
Billy thinking about the Kaplans as his real parents os completely the rigth choice. He was the Kaplan's son for 13 years more than he ever was Wanda and Vision son for.
I'm sorry but Billy identifying himself as a Kaplan more than identifying as a Maximoff is the closest we got of his Comic backstory so far.
And honestly? Considering how they are handling him in this show have this little bit of Comics!Billy was a suprise, but a very welcomed one.
Seeing reality from the pov of Lilia in her trial episode was so cool but i genuinely believe i would have gone crazy way before 100 years old if my reality was that confusing all the time.
Also idk why but seeing young Lilia at the of the episode + the music during the credits made me emotional and i almost cried.
Also her last words being that she loved being a witch? That's gow you break my heart. After who knows how many years hating her gifts she learns to love them just to die seconds later (Saving her coven this time)
Agatha/Agnes didn't exist in westview before the Hex. No one living there knew who she was.
For the people living in westview Agnes is just some Lady who had the biggest bad luck to move in into a new town at the same moment that a crazy woman decided to process her grief by making everyone live in sitcom land.
The only thing they know about her is that she tried to figth Wanda and in their eyes she lost and was put into another spell/ lost her mind helping free them.
No one in westview really knew Agatha but they all took care of her for 3 years anyway. And that shows how much heartwarming and welcoming westview is as a town.
Vision had really chosen a good place to raise a family and grow old together.
Billy said that he can sense Tommy but can't find him so it gives us two theories
1) Tommy also find another body (From other teenager who died at the same time) but he's too far away and Billy magick is not strong enough for him to get an exact location (or very umprobably Tommy also has a sigil in him)
Or
2) Tommy didn't find a body but his and Billy's Souls are connected in a way where Tommy can't leave without his twin and the reason Billy can sense him but not find him is because Tommy is kinds like a ghost
I'm gonna need someone with video editing skills to put the chasing scenes from Agatha's and Billy's pov side by side pls i need to see how much more skills Agatha was imagining for both her and teen vs their actual skills level
So was Billy super close with Alice because she was the one who saw both Willian Kaplan die and Billy Maximoff re-borning?
Poor Ralph he's super traumatized by Agatha but i'm so happy we got at least some answers on him
Although we seem to all agree that there was something off with the trial on episode 5 from all the theories i've seen nobody else thinks that this trial was a punishment for the coven.
I mean the rules say to not get off the road but when the coven try to scape the salem seven by flying they leave the road. Then they are pulled back down straight into the next "trial" witout a diferent road (notice in the other episodes not only does the filming ratio chenges there is always a path leading to the trial's door that matches the house).
I've seen some say it's actually Billy's trial because he is the one who gets his powers at the end of the episode and i believe that could be true as well. But for me this was a punishment, this trial was design to make the coven lose a witch ( "Punish Agatha" "Leave Agatha here with me and go back to the road without her") while all the others were about the witches knowledgeable on the craft.
I tougth Teen's/Billy's amulet was his spells book. During the first trial they make a point of showing wich one of the coven members checking their amulets are still with them.
Or the amulets were with them because they never took it of before the trial? Did he lost the book forever? The girls kept their amulets but not him because his fell when the brooms turned upside down? What is the point of the amulets?
They did not make Alice break her family curse just to kill her in the very next episode. I dont belive it, i can't believe it.
I also love how the salem seven are scary. I like scary stuff.
Teen is Billy, having this confirmed is sooo good i love to be proven rigth.
Wouldn’t be funny if they got Patti Lupone on Agatha All Along, made the show very musical and just never gave her a solo song?
Like we kinda of have her singing the ballad with the others on episode 2 and they had to sing the ballad again in this week's episode and they put her in the back with randon instruments.
Also i was Agatha singing? Like i know she is the main character BUT why is Agatha singing to break Alice's family curse?